January 8, 2013
Tomgram: Nick Turse, A War Victim's Question Only You Can Answer
[Note for TomDispatch Readers: There have been approximately 30,000 books published on the Vietnam War — and then there’s Nick Turse’s new book, Kill Anything that Moves: The Real American War in Vietnam. No one has ever described the American killing machine in that country the way he has; nor, as he did, tracked down Americans charged with war crimes by the U.S. military in that era, nor tramped through distant rural Vietnam to hear what it felt to be on the other side of massacres or experience the American-imposed “system of suffering” in those years. A decade in the making, it is a book that should reshape in fundamental ways how we remember the Vietnam War.Seymour Hersh, the reporter who broke the My Lai massacre story, calls it a “painful and important book,” a reminder of why “war should always be a last resort. We failed, as Turse makes clear, to deal after the Vietnam War with the murders that took place, and today — four decades later — the lessons have yet to be learned. We still prefer kicking down doors to talking.” Vietnam veteran Andrew Bacevich says that, with its publication, “the claim that My Lai was a one-off event becomes utterly unsustainable.” Daniel Ellsberg, the man who released the Pentagon Papers, writes, “No book I have read in decades has so shaken me as an American.” Vietnam veteran and novelist Tim O’Brien adds, “In the end, I hope, Turse’s book will become a hard-to-avoid, hard-to-dismiss corrective to the very common belief that war crimes and tolerance for war crimes were mere anomalies during our country’s military involvement in Vietnam.” (To read the full set of advanced comments on the book, click here.) In the coming months, you’re going to hear a lot about Kill Anything That Moves, which, I’m proud to say, is being published on January 15th by Metropolitan Books’ American Empire Project, which I co-run. TomDispatch readers who are Amazon users and buy Turse’s book off this link or off the book cover image embedded in the piece below will also be making a small contribution to this website (at no cost to you). However, since he is also TomDispatch’s managing editor and a regular at the site, we have a special offer for you: donate $100 (or more) to TomDispatch, which will help keep us rolling along in 2013, and you’ll get your own personalized, signed copy early. It’s a history-making book and one you’ll be proud to have. To check out our offer, visit our donation page by clicking here. Tom] In late December 2001, not long after Washington’s second Afghan War began, there was that wedding celebration in eastern Afghanistan in which 110 of 112 villagers were reportedly killed by American B-52 and B-1B bombers using precision guided weapons. Then there were the more than 40 Iraqi wedding celebrants (27 from one extended family, including 14 children) who died when U.S. planes struck their party at a village near the Syrian border back in May 2004, and the Afghan bridal party of 70 to 90 who were taken out by a U.S. airstrike on a road near the Pakistani border in July 2008. (The bride and 46 of those accompanying her died, according to an Afghan inquiry, including 39 women and children.) Added to this list should be the 24 unarmed Iraqi men, women, and children, ranging in age from 3 to 76, murdered by U.S. Marines in November 2005 in the long-forgotten Haditha massacre. And the 14-year-old girl whom American soldiers gang-raped and murdered along with her family in Mahmudiya, south of Baghdad, the next year. And then there was the headline-grabbing case of those 16 civilians, nine of them children, 11 from one family, reportedly slaughtered (and some of their corpses burned) by Staff Sergeant Robert Bales in two southern Afghan villages in the course of a single night in March 2012. Let’s not forget either the 12 Iraqis, including two Reuters employees, shot dead (and two children badly wounded) on a Baghdad street in July 2007 by the laughing crew of an Apache helicopter, as revealed in an infamous video released by WikiLeaks. There were also the 60 children (and up to 30 adults) who died in the Afghan village of Azizabad on an August night in 2008 while attending a memorial service for a tribal leader who had been, villagers reported, anti-Taliban. That, too, was thanks to air strikes. There were also those three (or more) Afghan civilians hunted down “for sport” in the summer of 2010 by a self-appointed U.S. “kill team” who were collecting trophy body parts. And there were the 10 boys, including two sets of brothers, collecting wood for their families in Afghanistan's Kunar Province early in 2011, who were attacked by U.S. helicopters. Only one wounded boy survived. Or most recently, the 11 Yemeni civilians, including women and children, in a Toyota truck killed by a U.S. airstrike and initially labeled “al-Qaeda militants.” Such a list, of course, only scratches the surface of a reality that we in the United States have hardly noticed and so have to expend no effort whatsoever to ignore. Unlike for the victims of 9/11 or more recently of Newtown, there will be no memorials, no teddy bears, no special rites, no solemn ceremonies. Nothing. The distant dead of our wars have largely paid the price in silence and anonymity for what the U.S. intelligence community likes to call the last superpower’s duty of being a “global security provider” — and which elsewhere often looks more like inflicting mayhem on local populations. In addition, the particular form of “security” we’ve brought to such areas via the U.S. military continues even after we leave. U.S. troops are gone from Iraq, for example, but the violence our invasion and occupation set loose has never ended. Iraq Body Count has just issued its report on rising deaths from violence in that country in 2012, both among the Iraqi police (922) and civilians (4,471). It concludes: “In sum the latest evidence suggests that the country remains in a state of low-level war little changed since early 2009, with a ‘background’ level of everyday armed violence punctuated by occasional larger-scale attacks designed to kill many people at once.” We bear genuine responsibility for this, but no longer care a whit. It’s good that one American did care and has spent the last decade preparing to help us remember what kind of “security” our wars have long brought to such distant regions. Nick Turse’s new book, Kill Anything that Moves: The Real American War in Vietnam, paints a memorable portrait of the war that, unlike Iraq and undoubtedly someday Afghanistan, we can’t seem to forget. Today, from his groundbreaking work on civilian suffering, he suggests the one way the “Vietnam analogy” really does apply to Iraq and Afghanistan. Tom
“So Many People Died”
The American System of Suffering, 1965-2014
By Nick Turse
Pham To looked great for 78 years old. (At least, that’s about how old he thought he was.) His hair was thin, gray, and receding at the temples, but his eyes were lively and his physique robust — all the more remarkable given what he had lived through. I listened intently, as I had so many times before to so many similar stories, but it was still beyond my ability to comprehend. It’s probably beyond yours, too.
Pham To told me that the planes began their bombing runs in 1965 and that periodic artillery shelling started about the same time. Nobody will ever know just how many civilians were killed in the years after that. “The number is uncountable,” he said one spring day a few years ago in a village in the mountains of rural central Vietnam. “So many people died.”
Visit our sister sites:
Recent Posts5 days ago…
2 days ago…
Tomgram: Bill McKibben, Time Is Not on Our Side
Tomgram: Engelhardt, Apocalypse When? 2 weeks ago…
Tomgram: Rebecca Solnit, 2013 as Year Zero for Us — and Our Planet 2 weeks ago…
Tomgram: Ira Chernus, The Mideast Surprise of 2013?
Recent Highlights2 months ago…
6 weeks ago…
Tomgram: Oded Na'aman, Is Gaza Outside Israel?
Tomgram: Engelhardt, An Obit for the General
Consider supporting TomDispatch by making a donation. Click here.
Sent to firstname.lastname@example.org — why did I get this?
unsubscribe from this list | update subscription preferences
The Nation Institute · 116 E. 16th Street · New York, NY 10003
I have ordered three of these books. I will be passing them around.
On Tue, Jan 8, 2013 at 5:00 AM, TomDispatch <email@example.com> wrote: